>>19883391Looking through this, No, he is not a cheater as far as can be proven.
However it is something that is cause for concern and definitely makes him suspect enough for further investigation if POGEYMENS was a "serious" sport, something it is not.
If anything it showcases the inherent flaw in GameFreak being so halfhearted with Hacked Pokémon and legality in general.
That said, i do think he could at least bothered to get rid of the ball, something that does not require much effort compared to the other shit, regardless of if he is a hacker or breeder or RNG abuser or whatever.
I would personally say that the fact that he did such a mistake in the first place make me doubtful that he himself Genned since double checking Ball/Pokémon combinations on shit you receive from other players are among the earlier things you pick up when doing that.