I decided to put my top 3 for each gen (in no particular order).
>>20587361Great taste, a solid 9/10. Walrein's a bro and one of two pokemon that survived a recent Emerald nuzlocke I did.
>>20586636Not a fan of dragonite, but your taste is 7/10 otherwise. Stoutland's a great revenge killer.
>>20586635Not big on aegislash, but your taste is an 8/10 otherwise. Brobat's so much fun to use both ingame and competitively.
>>20586225You have wonderful taste, 8/10. Mega ampharos is one of my favorite megas, gotta love that lightning god mane.
>>205860228/10, great taste. Not enough people like autist cat (me included), but I consider people who do to have good taste. Whimsicott's great too, it's my favorite prankster.
>>205859499/10, you are everything good in the pokemon fanbase. Is scolipede your favorite 'mon?
>>20585935Oh hey, it's the Dawn guy. 7/10 taste, not big on tyranitar or conkeldurr, but you still have pretty good taste.
>>20585778I remember the glove phase, I thought I was so cool. Anyway, 9/10 taste, you like some bro-tier pokemon. Furret's a favorite of mine in nuzlockes.
>>205856279/10, who knew /vp/ had such good taste? Mega absol's great, I'm running one in my main team in Y version.
>>20585434Don't give up, anon! I still love you! Also 8/10 taste, rayquaza's one of my favorite legendary pokemon of all time. Its design is wonderful.
I'd rate everybody else's great taste, but I'm hungry.
