>>26465830Bibarel learns the trickier water Hm's, and is actually beefy enough to maybe threaten an enemy with Strength or Waterfall.
Linoone gets no HM's Bibarel doesn't, and can't learn Waterfall or Dive, but gets Pickup, which lets it give money, pokeballs, and the occasional TM to you.
Linoone has another flaw, however. It is outperformed in its own game by either Tropius or Sharpedo. Bibarel is a rock solid HM slave, regardless of game. I brought one into SS, White 2, and X, where it performed admiribly each time. I wouldn't take Linoone into any game I could take Bibarel into.
I vote Bibarel.
>>26465862And Mew is not the best HM slave because it can't learn crabhammer.
>>26465851 
