>>27668478Actual musician here. I'll try to be as objective as possible
Going off official ones at the bottom only:
>Pokemon centre I'm guessing it's meant to be some kind of tango style but fails miserably. Violin sound is horrible, accordion rhythm sounds like something my 14-year-old self would have composed for a school project.
>Waterfall CaveI can't listen to this. The melody is almost a quartertone flat. Please don't put this in an actual game.
>Quaver townI don't think anyone actually had a melody in their head writing this. Melody and chords bear little to no relation. Some of it sounds not too bad but there are a lot of passing notes that don't fit at all.
>Quaver GymActually pretty good, not a fan of the drums but that's subjective. No objective complaints here.
>Foster BattleEhh, sounds like someone wrote the chords first and then tried to fit the melody over it. Again, no actual real melody, just noodling over the chords (and doesn't fit in a few places)
>Rival battleWhat the ever loving fuck is that synth doing in the fast bit. Did someone drop a kitten on their keyboard? These are just random notes, seriously, just that one part ruins it. Rest of it is not too bad, but nothing special.
>Trainer battleThe bit starting at 0:13 is ok, otherwise I can't remember the rest of it after half a minute of listening to it.
>Wild BattleTotal ripoff of gen 2 battle theme.
I'm tired of listening to this now. The only actual memorable melodies are the Pokemon centre and gym theme, which obviously these guys didn't write. If I missed anything you feel is fantastic music, tell me which one to listen to. Otherwise I'm going to go ahead and assume that
1) the rest of the music is the same standard, and
2) OP has no idea what he's talking about.
