What makes a good game /vp/?

I'm kinda intrested.

Is it one that sets you free and you play like you're in an open world? Do you okay like you're going on a story adventure?

Are you a nobody who fights his way to the top, are you a chosen hero saving there world from people using Gods

Is a good game innovative, or is it a game that's suposed to stand the test of time?

What kind of difficulty should their be? Should it be adjustable? in a non bullshit way

I'm curious to what makes a good game for /vp/.

They only thing I think everyone could agree on is if the world should be somewhat alive