Over the past months there have been a couple of threads of people posting how much they liked Diamond/Pearl/Platinum.
The replies were anything from total agreement to absolute disagreement.
As I personally really like D/P/Pt I wanted to give an actual conclusive thread a chance, collecting as many arguments as possible.
Pretty much discussing whether the games are good or shit, whether sinnoh is good or shit, whether the dex is good or shit etc. Please keep hg/ss out of this though