>>28825416Ash is a moron and his Pikachu has no Light Ball, so he's basically dead in the water. In fact, all of his pokemon except maybe Hawlucha have godawful moves and abilities.
Manga Red also wastes a slot on non-light ball Pikachu, but at least his Espeon and snorlax have decent sets... or would if they had the necessary items (Chesto Berry and Life Orb)
Origins Red has decnt moves, but he fucks it up with having Charizard-X go Mixed with no Dragon type moves and has terrible moves on that Scyther as well.
Game Red at least bothers to use Light ball, but his Pikachu's moves aren't that great. However, he at least bothers to have competent Venusaur and Blastoise.
Games Red would probably win.