>>29451664Because shitposting.
It's always starts as
>Why is HGSS a piece of shit?because HGSS is a well received game here and it's easier to bait with well received games, whcih is why HGSS and BW2 receive the most "criticism" threads. No one shitposts about DP because it's generally agreed upon that DP are weaker entries due to the tiny dex that is completely inbalanced in terms of typing.