>>30893662Played enjoyed both, colosseum was better.
What made them so good?
Gritty atmosphere with foes that felt actually dangerous?
Every battle was double battle?
Time spent exploring well-developed locations with distinct personalities rather than having to traverse routes?
Not feeling like a ten year old on an adventure like all the others?
Third gen pokemon being objectively the best?
Shadow pokemon mechanics feel like your team has an actual character arc as you get to know them?
Starters being umbreon and espeon?