>>31202648This.
Some people didn't like ash acting like a noob in BW, other did like because he was fun or whatever.
Some people didn't like Ash in XY because he was special, have a girl swooning for him and he doesn't struggle enough to win. Some people did like because he isn't a loser 90% of the time and actually get some development for a change.
Seriously, it's impossible please everyone everytime, people just should enjoy what you will have for the current series and don't be a bitch for the whole series.
I liked XY Ash, it was a nice change from what we have from Ash every series. I like SM Ash for act like a kid, but not being an incompetent battler.
But, yeah, BW Ash is shit.