Hilbert > Red (FRLG) > Ethan (HGSS) > Brendan (E) > Brendan (RS) > Lucas (DP) > Lucas (Pt) > Calem > Brendan (ORAS) > Nate
Can't really compare Gen I Red and Gen II Ethan since their style is so much stockier and it felt like the series took a different direction after.
DP Lucas has that classic Trainer vibe to him, but he feels kinda forgotten
Pt Lucas isn't super bad, but his stubby scarf and rounded zipper look kinda dumb
Calem is tall and lanky, and we had done blue jackets enough by that point
ORAS Brendan is all weird
Nate is dressed like a blind palm tree