To finally end this hell of Canon Character and Canon Starter I did a quick investigation and here are the results:

Red: Bulbasaur
- Game Artwork: Bulbasaur and Charmander
- Anime (Origins): Charmander
- Manga: Bulbasaur

Gold: Cyndaquil
- Game Artwork: Chikorita and Totodile
- Anime (Legend of the Thunder): Cyndaquil
- Manga: Cyndaquil

Kris: Chikorita or Totodile
- Game Artwork: --
- Anime (Legend of the Thunder): Totodile
- Manga: Chikorita

Lyra: Chikorita
- Game Artwork: Chikorita
- Anime: --
- Manga (She is just Kris but with Lyra's clothes): Chikorita

Brendan (RSE): Mudkip
Brendan (ORAS): Treecko
- Game Artwork (RSE): Torchic
- Anime (Movie Opening): Mudkip
- Manga: Mudkip

- Game Artwork (ORAS): Treecko
- ORAS Animated Trailer: Treecko
- Manga: Mudkip

May (RSE): Torchic
May (ORAS): Torchic
- Game Artwork (RSE): Torchic and Mudkip
- Anime: Torchic
- Manga: Torchic

- Game Artwork: --
- ORAS Animated Trailer: Torchic and Mudkip
- Manga: Torchic

Lucas: Piplup or Turtwig
- Game Artwork: Piplup
- Anime (Movie Opening): --
- Manga: Turtwig

Dawn: Piplup
- Game Artwork: Chimchar
- Anime: Piplup
- Manga: Piplup

(1/2)