I couldn't post this because that thread got closed, though I agree with that other guy that Fear Factor Phony is when the dub went to hell, but a lot of TPCi dub fanboys don't even get their facts straight and bash the 4Kids dub for shit their dub is even more guilty of doing- it is the TPCi dub that is dogshit compared to the 4Kids dub, and here's why.
First, TPCi dub was shit in DP, to the Jimmy Neutron anon:
- They didn't keep the original dialogue and rewrote stuff out the wazoo, TPCi Team Rocket being an even further departure from the Japanese TR than 4Kids Team Rocket was. They also inserted Ash and Brock gay jokes not in the Japanese Version, called Ash a noob, etc.
- They only kept 40 ish% of the original Japanese music: TPCi replaced the other 60% in DP, only the Movies were spared the OSTs, which even 4Kids kept all the OST in 2 of the 3 AG Movie dubs as well, and 96% in the other one, so that's not an excuse.
- The voice acting in the DP dub was terrible compared to what 4Kids did, Ash sounding like a chain smoker and James with a cold, among others.
And the TPCi dub of XY and SM is worse than the 4Kids dub ever was:
A) They replace like 85% of the OST now in the Sun and Moon Series, even 4Kids never got this bad outside of Movie 1 and 3.
B) We got 7 episodes with only 1 piece of Japanese music kept in this last season, again, even 4Kids never did this.
C) The I Choose You Movie kept only 1/55 pieces of Japanese music (which even 4Kids kept 100% OST in the Lucario Movie dub, to tell you how terrible TPCi has gotten).
D) TPCi still censor the dub now:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J20SyAZYNJE [Embed]
E) TPCi still Americanize it by removing kanji for Z-Moves + in general as of the XY dub onwards.
F) TPCi's voice acting is still garbage to this day, sorry, not sorry.
It amazes me TPCi fanboys will call the 4Kids dub dogshit when the TPCi dub is the true dogshit here: defend their garbage, pls.
TPCi Dub Fanboys Are Retarded
>>34165567 Yeah, the TPCi dub is dogshit.
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>34165787 As old as it takes to hammer home the point of how overrated and trash the current Pokemon dub is- fact I haven't gotten a reply back says it all about how people make up lies to defend the dub now.
Anonymous
>>3416580 Well, yeah, I didn't get a reply back so I'm hammering home the point the dub is ass now- you can't defend this, really.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KS-u1rVFoYU Anonymous
>>34165803 >Well, yeah, I didn't get a reply back so I'm hammering home the point the dub is ass now- you can't defend this, really. >https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KS-u1rVFoYU [Embed] Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>34165873 See:
- TPCi still Americanizes by erasing kanji and Z move text just like 4Kids did, and censors apples as berries, peas and carrots as veggies, and even 4Kids got the rice balls right a few times (see: Pokemon Paparazzi), no better than 4Kids on that.
- TPCi still puts out blank Z move text and erases text too, like with the Kalos Gym Leaders, they're no better than 4Kids were on this either.
- TPCi still mistranslated stuff like in DP191 saying Ash would become a Pokemon Master if he won the League, which was wrong, in Japanese it was said by Satoshi it was only one STEP to do so, followed by the Champion's League. And anything involving Team Rocket from TPCi is the worst dialogue in the dub, ever.
- 4Kids replaced more music in Kanto Movie 1 and Movie 3 in Early Johto than in Seasons 4-8 and kept more OST in Movies 4-8, in Johto and Hoenn, than in Kanto/OI Movies. In addition, TPCi replaces more music than 4Kids did in Kalos and Alola in both the Anime and Movies now.
Again, TPCi does the same shit people bash 4Kids for doing, except worse, save for editing. Hypocrisy, utter hypocrisy.
>>34165870 What's embarrassing is it's the truth about the dub, and TPCi fans won't accept it.
Anonymous
>>34165873 Also, let's not forget TPCi making the intros shorter for the openings on TV than 4Kids did: 4Kids had minute long OPs, TPCi has thirty second OPs now.
And TPCi fanboys will defend this dogshit as being better: yeah, no, TPCi's dub does all the same shit the 4Kids dub did wrong, but even worse at this point.
Anonymous
>>34165923 No, what's embarrassing is that you have to samefag your shitty thread that nobody cares about. What TPCi fanboys are you even talking about? Nobody gives a shit about the anime here besides /padt/ and I'm pretty sure they're pro sub. Fuck off there weeb.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>34165969 You cared enough to reply to the shitty thread on dogshit dubbing itself.
The TPCi fanboys who act like only 4Kids dub did the shit the TPCi dub also does.
And yeah, not a weeb for telling the truth about the dub. I'll gladly watch the older seasons in the dub, but the newer ones are cancer.
Anonymous
>>34165923 >>34165947 I'm not defending the TPCi dub. I hate it too. But the 4Kids dub isn't the holy grail that you think it is either.
Both Pokemon dubs are shit.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>34166006 The 4Kids dub is less shit than the TPCi dub, that's all I'm arguing, at least it had better openings, voice acting, and music quality on the whole. And script wise, 4Kids Team Rocket was at least understandable, TPCi Team Rocket is impossible to understand.
Given the fact TPCi still Americanizes and edits shit like 4Kids used to on top of the (in my opinion) drop in quality of TR writing, voice acting, and OST kept along with opening theme length, I see one dub as less shit than the other.
Anonymous
>>34165567 Are you Tim or that guy who wanted Veronica Taylor in the 20th movie?
Anonymous
>>34166880 I think he's
OldSchoolPokemonFan. Anonymous
>>34166892 Think OP is one of those people from Twitter who are nostalgic of the 4Kids dubs.
Anonymous
>>34166933 >>34166892 I don't know who the fuck either of those people are, but it doesn't take nostalgia to see the TPCi dub is an inferior production to the 4Kids dub at all at this point.
1/55 pieces of Japanese music kept in Movie 20's dub, by TPCi, vs 54/54 pieces of Japanese music kept in Movie 8's dub, by 4Kids.
Defend this drop in quality, please.
And don't tell me TPCi don't still rewrite the scripts because they still do, "Might makes right," "Hey, dude," "Having fun while we run," and "Yo ho, Ho-Oh!" were in the Movie 20 dub.
The TPCi dub lacks any sort of quality on any front: I'm not saying the 4Kids dub was great, but it was sure as heck decent compared to this tripe.
Anonymous
>>34166933 And there's more nostalgia going around for the TPCi dub given that they are as guilty of rewriting scripts (if not more for Team Rocket), hacking up openings (actually, worse than 4Kids on this front, 30 seconds from mid BW onwards to SM), and still censor the dub in XY and SM now like 4Kids used to, on top of that.
It'd be one thing if TPCi improved anything, but they do all the shit 4Kids did wrong, and all they succeeded in doing was replacing even more of the Japanese music in the last few years than 4Kids ever did, gave us bad voice acting, and an impossible to understand Team Rocket, script wise.
Like, where's the defense for this other than "Herp they are this dude on some random sites I stalk 'cause I said so," really? It's impossible to defend, really.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>34168149 Oh, I do, it's just amazing to me people will bash 4Kids but then let TPCi get away with doing all the same exact shit, and giving us even worse voice acting, scripts, and music to boot.
It's obvious how far the quality of the Pokemon dub has fallen, really, sub is *the* only way to go at this point, that's what I'm arguing here.
The dub may never have been amazing, but the modern day dub is pure trash, that's what I'm saying.
Anonymous
>>34168212 Wow, are you that assblasted over a dub?
Also see
>>34165873 Anonymous
>>34168244 You're assblasted enough to be a double standard'd TPCi dub fanboy, that says it all, see
>>34165923 Anonymous
>>34168378 Dude, people already told you that both versions of the TPCI and 4Kids dubs sucks and will still continue watching the subs. Like I say, just stick with the subs and move on.
Anonymous
>>34168442 The TPCi dub is even worse than the 4Kids dub, though, that's my point.
I have moved on, the dub can fuck off, but at least Veronica Taylor wasn't as shitty of a VA as Sarah Natochenny, etc.
Anonymous
>>34168489 And you expect us to agree with you on that? Because many anime fans sees dubbing anime in general as bad. If you like 4Kids dubbing of Pokemon that's fine, but don't expect us to have the same mindset as you.
Anonymous
>>34168548 I'm not saying you have to agree or disagree, but I'm pointing out that TPCi is as guilty of things people bash 4Kids for in their own dub (hypocrisy), people lied about the DP dub when it changed tons of lines in the script from the Japanese Version and kept less than half the Japanese music still.
I think in terms of acting, music, and writing (at least for the Rockets), TPCi do an even worse job than 4Kids did, that's all I'm saying in the end. That part's subjective, but the above isn't.
Anonymous
>>34168584 You come to the wrong place then because there's has been little to no threads talking about the dubding of Pokemon and there's no people that are fans of them here.
Anonymous
>>34168629 There were TPCi apologists in the thread started by a guy talking about the dub, friend, I was addressing that stupidity since the thread got locked.
And trust me, the dub can fuck off entirely for me as well at this point, I'm just pointing out how shit the current dub is.
Anonymous
>>34168644 You do know he trolls people, right?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>pokemon ashnime who gives a fuck
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>34168720 I do not, but that says it all, especially given where we are I guess.
Anonymous
>>34168489 Are you implying Veronica is bad at all?
Anonymous
>>34169430 Veronica Taylor was a pretty good Ash: may be not as good as Rica, but solid. Too bad she only had 8 years, whereas Sarah Natochenny has had the role for 11 years and is still a bad Ash, only getting defended by the TPCi fanboys and shills like Daman Mills (as really, the dub is by now).
Anonymous
>>34169816 >TPCi fanboys and shills Again, you're in the wrong place.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>34169896 I wasn't originally since the thread on the topic got closed, but yeah, I see what you mean.
tl;dr Fuck the dub nowadays.