>>34722995I pretty much look at both thelowest Smogon team as well as the ingame tier list on their forums then I make a nice judgement on that.
For example: here is the PU tier list for Gen 4http://
www.smogon.com/forums/threads/pu-old-gens-discussion.3597643/#post-7260264And there is the ingame iter list for Platinum:
http://www.smogon.com/ingame/misc/dpp_plat_ingametiersAnd then I would pretty much use a selection of Pokemon found in both the PU tier and in the ingame mid tier or below.
For another example, Lillipup (Stoutland) is in the lowest competitive tier in Gen 5, but it's A/High tier in the ingame list in BW2, so I wouldn't use it.
I also do other self-imposed rules such as No Legendaries, no starters (if they happen to be in the tier, which most are not), no gimmick mons such as Slaking/Wobbuffet/Shedinja/etc no items in battle, no going above a Boss Battle's level, and other things.
there are also some Pokemon I would never use, such as Luvdisc. Luvdisc is just too shit and would simply resort to cheese strats which wouldn't be fun at all.