Quoted By:
I'd like to start that off this thread by saying that if you're one of those that says Ice should resist Water, you probably are a part of the majority of the world who has never seen snow in real life before. And I don't hate or belittle you for that. But you still lack a very basic understanding or awareness of the world around you, for failing to understand that water is by definition warmer than ice, and will melt it if poured on it.
>but if it's REALLY cold, the water would freeze!
Well then, at that point it would be analogous to using an Ice Type move on an Ice Type, wouldn't it?
>but if you put water in the freezer, it turns to ice!
That would be essentially the equivalent of attacking a Water Type with an Ice move, not the other way around. Attacking an Ice Type with a Water move would be like pouring a glass of water on snow.
>insert extremely specific scientific scenario where Water being super effective on Ice makes sense
Not relevant. Trainers aren't battling in exteremly specific conditions like that.
There literally is no rational reason for which Ice would resist water.
