>>36728556the physical/special split is an upgrade, you have to be simple to think otherwise
more complexity and choices to the battle system IS an improvement, more pokemon having stab moves and being viable IS an improvement
Yes, the old system worked but by gen 3 it was obvious that it was not very thought through and many pokemon were rendered quite useless by the type categories
The ONE upside to pre-split is that defensive pokemon could have specific types they resisted really reliably, but now it's a bit easier to target the lower defense AND super effective