I don't care what your favorite game is, but you're HGSS are objectively the weakest games pre-Gen 6 and there's no denying that. If you unironically defend them you're either underage, a fucking moron, or both. It fixed none of the problems of the originals and was a worse game overall than both the originals, the prior games that gen, and the prior set of remakes.
>gross Gen IV graphics, bad mix of sloppy 3D and messed up 2D, both Gen III and V look better for different reasons
>Gen IV lag everywhere
>ruined Gen II character designs
>ruined Gen II music which was objectively the best soundtrack in the series
>literally had to include an item to fix the music by turning it into chiptunes again
>level curve was improved but still sucked cock
>literally the only extra content was the Pokeathlon
>Pokewalker was a useless gimmick
>follower Pokemon is a useless gimmick beloved only by spergs
>Pokemon distribution wasn't fixed at all
>copy/paste of worst Battle Frontier
>ugly menu interfaces out the ass
>retarded full-touch interfaces on PC, PokeGear, etc etc that don't even work like they should
>somehow manages to add less content to it's base games than FRLG added 6 years prior
>poor use of the bottom screen
>literally playing GSC is more enjoyable