Probably the same person who made that awful Pocahontas grass raccoon.
M8, your art has improved but ffs, stop making all your starter sets mammal.
The grass mouse or whatever the fuck looks like an amputee Fennekin, and none of the mammalian grass starters are fully green anyway.
I give you props for the fire bag since that’s pretty unique for a starter, but it looks so boring as well, it’s just needs a pattern of some sort.
As for the water starter, it looks like you wanted to repeat that awful beaver starter you did before, but now changed it into an otter (?), which wouldn’t make sense because we already have an otter for a water starter.
3/10 you improved but only slightly, try drawing the starters actually showcasing their attacks and not clutter them with anime expressions.