>>37814614For Maxie, the old version hands down. I really don't like the specs on new Maxie, they remind me of those granny glasses with the chains hanging down the sides. I know what they were going for, but it just doesn't work IMO.
Archie, on the other hand, is a bit more of a toss-up. The new look is brimming with "personality", and the wetsuit really fits a man with an obsession with the sea. But on the other hand, old Archie has a very old style pirate merchant vibe to him, like he's spent many, many days on a ship and had a whole bunch of shady-ass dealings with stolen shit. They're both good designs with their own appeals.
If you have to take their respective teams into account, old designs win by a landslide because new Shelly is terribad. 
