[41 / 7 / ?]
>1996 - [9.0] Pokémon Red/Green (Red/Blue/Yellow) The concept of forming a party of monsters that join you is not new to JRPGs, but Pokémon implemented it in a smooth, never-seen before way. It's a solid game, solid JRPG and one of the best games of the GB.>1999 - [10.0] Pokémon Gold/Silver (Crystal) Expanded even more an already revolutionary game. Being a sequel story to the original, included locations of the previous game as well as trading compatibility with it's predecessor. Introduced new concepts like genders, types and numerous new battle mechanics. Tried to be one of the most immersive GB games of it's time with it's day-night cycle, as well as daily events - perfect for a handheld game. Crystal went even further with the female protagonist, Pokémon animations and online battling.>2002 - [7.0] Pokémon Ruby/Sapphire (Emerald) Disappointing game that scrapped many of the game mechanics built until then. Featured a smaller map, barely any time events and no compatibility with previous games. Introduced new Pokémon, but only a bit more than half of the total were obtainable. Introduced new battle mechanics, but created a great gap between casual and competitive play with the introduction of Hidden and Effort Values. It's still a fun core Pokémon game with the mechanics that everybody loves, though.>2004 - [7.0] Pokémon Fire Red/Leaf Green Overall lazy remake of the original, with few new content and reusing many assets of the previous game.>2006 - [8.0] Pokémon Diamond/Pearl (Platinum) Pokémon's first step into 3D went smooth, with good use of the new hardware. It's a pleasant game that follows the formula stablished in Ruby/Sapphire. Went on par with the expectations.>2009 - [8.5] Pokémon Heart Gold/Soul Silver Also made good use of the new hardware, updating a great game from the GB to the DS. The only core game to ever have a general following Pokémon mechanic.
Anonymous
>2010 - [8.5] Pokémon Black/White (Black 2/White 2) With a greater focus on the narrative and updated aesthetics, it's a solid JRPG on it's own, considering it's kids demographic.>2013 - [8.0] Pokémon X/Y Pokémon's full transition to 3D didn't went so smooth. The great Pokémon battle models badly contrasted with the poor and bland map and character designs. The narrative went a step behind and the game difficulty plummeted. It still added good gameplay mechanics on par with the expected for the first Pokémon 3DS game, like Pokémon Amie, character customization and global online interaction.>2014 - [7.5] Pokémon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire The bad 3D graphics used on X/Y became even more aberrant. Great elements from the previous game like Secret Bases and Battle Frontier were either badly adapted or scrapped - unforgivable considering the 3DS capabilities.>2016 - [8.5] Pokémon Sun/Moon (Ultra Sun/Ultra Moon) Similar to Black/White, Sun/Moon had updated aesthetics and greater narrative focus. An evolution of the previous games and also a solid JRPG on it's own, also considering it's kids demographic.>2019 - [7.5 ~ 8.0] Pokémon Sword/Shield Probably something on the level of Pokémon X/Y. The 5 Objetively Best Pokémon Games: 1st - Pokémon Gold/Silver (Crystal) 2nd - Pokémon Red/Green (Red/Blue/Yellow) 3rd - Pokémon Heart Gold/Soul Silver - Pokémon Black/White (Black 2/White 2) - Pokémon Sun/Moon (Ultra Sun/Ultra Moon) GB Average: 9.5 GBA Average: 7.0 DS Average: 8.3 3DS Average: 8.0 GB > DS > 3DS > GBA
Anonymous
>>38090662 >>38090666 The GB games suck you stupid nostalgiatard why would anyone pick HGSS over gold and silver
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >rby that high >hgss on the same level as SM and 1.5 points lower than it's objectively inferior versions yikes
Anonymous
Actually not bad OP. Agreed for the most part
Anonymous
>>38090697 You’re dumb. Why would hgss be lower than gold and silver. OP didn’t even give a reason as to why. He just said it was like DPP and that it had following Pokémon. How the fuck does that put it below GS. And why does there have to be decimals, just use the whole number you idiot. I swear this board is full of idiots.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 All Pokémon games are bad games and should score no higher than a 6 or MAYBE 6.5 out of 10 at best
most should be below a 5/10
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>G/S/C that high I want to call it nostalgia, but then you also overrated ultracutscenes
Anonymous
so weird seeing a decent different opinion in here feels like I'm not even part of the hivemind anymore love that you placed USUM where it deserves
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >>38090666 >ORAS rated higher than FRLG >Don't include Crystal and Platinum >USUM as the 3rd best game Anonymous
You forgot Let's Go. Incomplete list discarded.
Anonymous
>>38090720 The way the list is described it's clear that it was made within the context of their release dates. GS were incredible improvements upon RBY mechanically and aesthetically; they were ambitious titles for their time. That's why I agree it deserves the highest score. HGSS remade these things but for its time was not a groundbreaking entry to the series. Saying I agree for the most part means that I agree that certain games are rated well and others lower.
I dont give two shits about decimal places and the semantics of one game being rated .5 or 1.5 above another, and the fact that you cant infer anything without being spoonfed makes me wonder why I'm replying to some sad idiot at all.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090763 Gen 7 was ass redditor go cry about the hive mind some more. For once it’s right: alola fucking sucks
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>Sword and Shield rated at all >Glossing over DP's problems >>>GSC at a 10
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >>38090666 ORAS shouldn't be higher than RSE. If anything it should be at 6/10 at most. Otherwise accurate.
Anonymous
>>38090776 This is some of the most retarded reasoning I’ve heard in a while. Imagine agreeing with decimal place ratings. You’re fucking retarded. Just rate the game on 1 to 10.
And GSC isn’t really groundbreaking since it’s literally Kanto 2 + Johto. The game doesn’t even give a shit about it’s own region.
Just because Iwata was able to fit the game onto a cartridge because Game Freaks retarded ass didn’t know how to develop doesn’t make it groundbreaking. It’s pathetic
Anonymous
>>38090776 >>38090813 Also your reasoning is retarded because OP places ORAS above RSE, which is below everything else. I would fucking argue that RSE is by far more groundbreaking than anything Gen 2 or 1 had to offer because it’s the first Pokémon game with a real story and color and distinguishable graphics. Yet ORAS is placed above it. idiot
Anonymous
Quoted By:
It's like fucking. You will always rebember the first one and have some feelings for it. But the second try is always a better fucking. Every single fuck in diferent pussy (console) issn't the same, but can be good too.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >>38090666 >my opinions are facts: the thread some of the shit you said are also objectively wrong but I have better things to do with my time
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 what a fucking retard
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090838 GSC were full color you retard.
Anonymous
>>38090662 >GS above the objectively superior HGSS >SM on the same level as HGSS when it should be near the bottom >ORAS above RS >RB being that high and above FRLG this is either really good bait or a seriously retarded OP
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090957 based illiterate retard
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >rating something better based off a feature that was Japan only Nice objective rating
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090838 >the first Pokémon game with a real story Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090776 >HGSS remade these things but for its time was not a groundbreaking entry to the series. >following pokemon >battle frontier >customizable safari zone >Arceus, Celebi and Pichu event >Pokewalker >17 intractable pokemon >449 available pokemon >additional routes, cave and dungeons >Pokéathlon >zero removed content >gym leader rematches >Monday Night Clefairies Whay more do you want? A hoenn postgame after the Kanto one?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090838 Why are you so mad anon
Anonymous
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 i can clearly tell that you never played a single pokemon game before gen 7 because you dont know shit and havent gotten a single thing right about any of the games
rule 2 stop posting and fuck off back to r/pokemon please
Anonymous
Lily
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >Objective This meme needs to die
Anonymouse
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >HGSS and B2W2 not at the top >ORAS scoring higher than FRLG >All third versions/improved versions not above their first versions. Fucking derail this stupid irrelevant thread.
Anonymous
Anonymous
>>38090662 Redditors will seethe about gsc
Anonymous
>>38092509 Gsc is literally the most reddit game ever made
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090692 Exactly. Why would they? Crystal is the best
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38090662 >xy on par of dpp >oras higher than anything Bullshit.
Anonymous
>>38092566 r/pokémon has better taste than /vp/ then
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>38091042 I don't agree with it completely, but I can respect this list. It sort of makes sense.
Anonymous