>>43121863HeartGold is easily the definitive johto experience, as well as the definitive POKEMON experience as a whole.
each of the starters are viable for their own reasons:
chikorita is for if you are female or just want to play on hard mode.
totodile is if you like pressing A a lot without thinking, as you only choose the pokemon that look cool
> however, cyndaquil has LITERALLY EVERYTHING GOOD ABOUT BOTH AND THEN SOME.it is cute early on to appeal to females. its typing for the region makes it the intermediate difficulty. the final evolution is bodacious and cool, but not overpowered; you have to still apply some strategy in order to make typhlosion work, but it isn't an annoying shitmon like meganium.
with the multiple ways you can use typhlosion, choosing him will always be entertaining and new.
cyndaquil is also more fitting for the canon.
pick cyndaquil.