>>44537665S tier: Dawn and May. Actually had a reason to exist and care about their journey other than being the girl of the season. Both also cute and likable
A tier: Lana. Liked her personality in the anime. What more can I say
B: Misty, Lillie, Mallow. Misty gets some points from me for being the original girl, not that into tomboys though. Mallow was likable. Lillie was fine other than the shit backstory gave her because they wanted to pussy out on making Lusamine evil.
C: Iris: She's cute but got rather annoying at times
D: Serena: Literally the definition of waifubait. Doesn't help she was part of the worst season of the anime
Unrated: Koharu. Haven't watched more than a couple episodes of the most recent season. What little of her I have seen, she seems cute and likable enough. Probably B or A if I watched more