>>457362697/10, some interesting ideas, would have been an awesome X/Y 2, if it happened. I'd like more plot than "Diantha is present and Lysander is the villain again". Could use a bit more development, but a great start.
>>45737574Some good gameplay ideas, but almost no actual plot. I'm interested in story specifically. 5/10 for trying. Would love to see gym leaders more involved in a main plot, as your first point mentions.
>>457376758/10, very original! The different approach than usual and focus more on an actual problem that needs to be solved as part of an adventure is appreciated, would lend itself well to plenty of mystery and hidden things to uncover.
>>457379595/10, I played Gen 1 already. It's fun, but I'd like something different, something new, something innovative. Return to roots still has some potential, though.
>>457379699/10, New approach again, very original! This is the kind of plot I'd want out of Pokemon. The world has many possibilities, and something different is more than welcome.
>>457391166/10, I like the plot involving rivals and actual choices. Having actual choices that matter isn't "doing nothing", it's innovation in a medium that thrives on interaction. Having the rival develop alongside you is a cool idea too, could ahve some good possibilities in conflict. Good job!
>>457394734/10. I like the "evil team is mad scientist" idea, but shonen protags are played out. The evil scheme of kidnapping your mom is a damsel in distress, which is very problematic. Do some research, iron out your ideas. There is the seed of something decent here. It can grow with some refinement.