>>45876821>you lose to every Physical attackerCounter, Scald are your answers to a physical attacker. These are tools Clefable doesn't have and Quagsire is naturally bulkier on the physical side than Clefable.
>Swampert has a better SpDef stat and can hit OKish due to it's better Offensive stats. Pert also has Seismic toss and Counter.Yes, because Swampert has higher BST. The only thing that sets Quagsire apart is Unaware but that is what makes it better as a wall than Swampert, because Swampert can always be used as setup bait. Quagsire outclasses Swampert even as a special wall if you put the proper investment into it.
Pert is a tank and a pivot. It's lacking in resistances and ability to be a real wall, and in the OP pic Heatran is the only true wall due to its numerous x4 resistances and immunities.
>>45877078I used this set on monotype ubers because water otherwise has no defensive answers to Xerneas. Quagsire used bulldoze to slow Xerneas enough for a revenge killer to take it out. You can even survive a Freeze Dry from scarf KW running that set.