Ash because my little genwunner faggot heart grew up watching his exploits while the moans he made any time he exerted himself made my peepee feel funny for reasons I didn't understand yet. While the nu-anime does feed into horny a lot more with his poses and a lot of faces that look like he just had the most satisfying nut in his life, the love just isn't there since he's practically a different character than the guy I grew up with.
But if we have to pick from the games,
Hilbert.is the one. He has such a sweet face and the scene with him getting all sweaty with the hiker on the Ferris Wheel leaves a lot to my imagination. The sun/moon ace trainer is pretty hot too.