Red
>Classic, iconic, THE Pokémon Trainer that defines how you see all Trainers
Ethan
>Cocky smirk exudes personality, outfit has utility like the hoodie and Pokégear
Brendan
>Kind of like a cocky jogger, a little too heavy in clothing for Kyushu, art doesn't have backpack which is a letdown
Red (FRLG)
>The washed-out colors are lame, the colors themselves aren't good, lacks a lot of the personality of the original, only looks right in HGSS
Brendan (Emerald)
>Sleek and cool, nowhere near as heavy, confident, green accents are nice, shorts over pants are stupid though
Lucas
>Bland and unassuming. The orange-pink is garish. Lacks presence and originality.
Lucas (Platinum)
>The jacket is awful, the scarf is ugly. Pants are an upgrade and he looks better at other angles without the backpack.
Ethan (HGSS)
>Colors are good, overall form is good, solid conversion to a more modern style, but the expression destroys whatever personality he had.
Hilbert
>Balanced as fuck, this looks good. Probably the best colors and form and shape. Actually cool.
Nate
>What the actual fuck were they thinking. A diving suit beneath trackshorts? A golf hat? Palm tree hair? And the eyes are creepy.
Calem
>Way too tall and lanky, too narrow. Completely derivative everywhere else.
Brendan (ORAS)
>Lacks solidity, unsure stance, overall downgrade. Decent take on clothes ruined by character form.
Elio
>It's alright, inoffensive, lacks any sort of impression, boring.
Elio (USUM)
>On the opposite scale, just silly and retarded.
Chase
>Preportions hurt it, basically just aping Red.
Victor
>Okay, clothing doesn't scream adventure and is kind of cartoonish