>>53454429These ultra humanoid designs with pre-defined personalities and characters are so bad and go so far against what separates pokemon from other monster training series (the fact that they are actual creatures that behave like animals in the world) that I legit think the only reasons someone could like them are:
1. They are actually a gay furry with a fursona who browses e621
2. They've been defending new designs from autistic genwunners for so long that they have convinced themselves that good designs are bad and that these bad designs are good because they're "smarter" or "more creative".
I don't want to live with a buff heel wrestler or secret agent, I want to live with essentially a glorified pet that can have a range of characters I project onto it from my own imagination through how it preformed in gameplay.
Also yes, Gen 1 has shit designs too, Mr. Mime and Jynx are awful and even back then anyone I talked thought they were awful. People have always thought this kinda design was shit.