because gf's writers are hacks and waifufags. the writing has been like this for a while, this is just the most blatant it's ever been. people just don't want to hear it because muh waifu.
>>54529512finally someone gets it. so many people going "uhh but if we'd let him meet the ogre it would've been exactly the same!! huh huh cuck" when, even if ogrepon did still choose us in the end, he might be more willing to accept it if he felt like he'd been given a fair chance, or just been happy he got to meet it. but we trolled him out of even that because carmine's a dick
