>>54685801It's not necessary or even wise for every Type matchup to make sense. What is necessary and what I fucking DEMAND is that
>no Type matchup makes ANTI-sense>no Type matchup simply ignores an obvious relationship that is SCREAMING with how obvious it should be and they just leave it as a neutral relationship for no discernable reasonFirst example would be Grass resisting Fire. If they did this is would clearly be anti-logic. Second example is Ice not resisting Electric for LITERALLY no reason when ice and snow notoriously are piss-poor electric conductors and it absolutely would and should logically resist it.
Fire resisting Fairy neither makes, nor doesn't make sense. It's just random. A rationale would be preferred, but as long as it isn't anti-logic you're free to do whatever you want in your fantasy elements chart. And since fairies are mythical there's a certain degree to which you can make up how they work in your setting and the audience can buy that's just what fairies are like in this universe.
The crux of our problems is that half of us view Ice resisting Water as an anti-logic relationship, and the other half of us are wrong.
