>>58224371BDSP is under DP. All the games are ranked inside their tier. I was going to put it in D tier but I felt like there wasn't even that big of a difference gap between DP and BDSP, so I put in the same tier.
SM is bad. The first Pokemon game I hated playing through. The only reason its not F tier is that SS exists which was way worse for me.
SV is carried by the DLC like I said. Plus the qol changes make a big difference.
Johto is my favorite region and Crystal is the perfect portrayal of it. I could go more in detail why I like HGSS less but it would take too long. Maybe later.