Quoted By:
Taking into account the whole lines.
>bulbasaur: objectively perfect monster design but not my personal fav 9/10
>chikorita: don't hate it but quite boring 4/10
>treecko: cool and awesome 10/10
>turtwig: badass turtle with a tree on its back, what's not to love? 10/10
>snivy: don't like the smug look but serperior is not bad 6/10
>chespin: chespin and chesnaught are good designs 8/10
>rowlet: don't like first two but decidueye is fine despite being humanoid 6/10
>grookey: i like grookey but fuck the others 2/10
>grass cat forgot name: no 0/10
Grass total: 55
>charmander: great design but never felt anything for it 7/10
>cyndaquil: love them 10/10
>torchic: too humanoid for me but saves it by being cool and not gay like nu-gen starters 7/10
>chimchar: always found it and monferno annoying but infernape is ok 6/10
>tepig: emboar is overhated but don't like the first two 5/10
>fennekin: don't care about them and braixen is too much 2/10
>litten: fuck incineroar 1/10
>scorbunny: no 0/10
>fuecoco: best switch era starter but that's not saying much 3/10
Fire total: 41
>squirtle: a turtle with cannons, fuck yeah 10/10
>totodile: an alligator brute, fuck yeah 10/10
>mudkip: a mud fish monster, fuck yeah 10/10
>piplup: an emperor penguin inspired by napoleon, fuck yeah: 10/10
>oshawott: first water dud, oshawott is the only good one: 2/10
>froakie: i secretly like frogadier more, but a ninja frog, fuck yeah 10/10
>gen 7 seal thing: no 0/10
>sobble: whoever designed this line should be thrown off a cliff 0/10
>quaxly: same as above but also skinned alive beforehand 0/10
Water total: 52
Water has more of my favourites, but I guess Grass is more consistent overall.