[54 / 13 / 1]
>as Naranja/Uva Academy language classes show, english, spanish, french, italian, japanese and chinese exist in the pokemon world >the "show a pokedex entry in a different language" feature was mentioned in-universe years ago, meaning german and korean (and american spanish I guess) should exist as well >there's even the case of XY postgame having Looker not understanding a tourist speaking another language. In western languages the tourist speaks japanese, but in the canon japanese version she speaks english We know Looker can speak the language of Sinnoh (Pt), Hoenn (ORAS), Unova (BW), Kalos (XY) and Alola (SM/USUM), and yet he can't speak english or "galarian" despite being able to talk to unovans just fine. Moreover, The Hidden Treasure of Area Zero shows Iono, a spanish streamer, is popular in both Spain/Paldea and the US/Unova, and has the language teacher confirming Unova does speak the same language as Paldea. Therefore we can conclude out of all the regions so far, only Galar speaks "galarian", while Unova speaks "paldean", given Looker has zero knowledge of the english language but he can speak the same tongue as unovans and paldeans. Maybe Alola has the same language as Kanto-Johto-Hoenn-Sinnoh given Hawaii's japanese population, but it's unlikely they would have english if not even Unova does.
Anonymous
>>58827392 Pokemon confirmed alternate universe where Spain took the entirety of the Americas
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827403 >galar jobs yet again Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827403 >pokemon world has zero to minimal anglo corruption Truly an idyllic world
Anonymous
Jokes on you it would match with how the american spanish version works. For decades the latin american localization was basically just a translation of the american one to the point some of them are surprised of spanish localized names and think the english ones are the default "correct" choice. ZA introduced a latin american localization and while they are finally adding their own names, most of the previous ones are still just a copy of the american localization>Korni the gym leader? Spain calls her Corelia. US calls her Korrina. Latam calls her... Korrina. >Isshu the western region? Spain calls it Teselia. US calls it Unova. Latam calls it... Unova. >Zumi the Elite Four? Spain calls him Narciso. US calls him Siebold. Latam calls it... Siebold. So maybe Unova's official language is american spanish and that's why they can understand Paldea's european spanish. It's not far from reality seeing how spanish is already taking over burgerland
Anonymous
>>58827392 Considering gen 10 will be in Poke-Indonesia, will they put some Dutch references in it?
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827483 God I want a netherlands region. Or germany. Let's hope for gen XI
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>knows japanese, spanish and french, but no english I wonder where Looker is from
Anonymous
pokemon secretly critiquing immigration
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>"fuck anglos" Based Handsome
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827462 >It's not far from reality seeing how spanish is already taking over burgerland Not as long as we cap the rest of you woketards trying to run over ICE agents. Reminder that LULAC chicano bullshit is dying off with the boomer radicals.
Anonymous
We know French is the spoken language in Kalos. As far back as the JP script for Red and Green, he says [ボン ジュール], and an NPC in XY tells us "The famous Professor Oak's grandson came here to the Kalos region the study abroad. He got 'Bonjour' down just fine, but he still always said 'Smell ya later!' when he left!". Can't recall if the "bonjour" line was in the JP script, but the broader strokes about him studying abroad was in the original JP script.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827571 ZA's whole plot reads as an allegory for immigration. I don't think it's a coincidence they went with a 5 year timeskip either, the whole thing has this post-2020 vibe of "we need to make peace with and adjust to a changed world"
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827571 It's "criticizing" and Unova being a functional, walkable, healthy, friendly and cultured version of burgerland with free healthcare when spanish becomes the most dominant language is the opposite of a critique to immigration lmao
Anonymous
>>58827783 >Can't recall if the "bonjour" line was in the JP script It was. Bonjour has always been the main "catchphrase" associated with the character in Japan, which is why he says it so often in Masters.
Anonymous
>>58827822 I know, I'm just unsure if the Japanese script for XY alludes to him picking up the phrase when he was in Kalos. Couldn't find a text dump to confirm.
Anonymous
>>58827392 >lore autism about languages >in Pokémon No point to it. You already thought more about it than GF ever did and will. There's no logic or thought about it. They just insert the mention of "other languages" whenever they feel like it, it never makes any sense.
Anonymous
>>58827857 Chew gum and walk. Two things can be true. The brand simultaneously has this background texture about language and culture while also leaning on the "human language" or "world of Pokemon" copouts anytime language is a plot point, like with Meowth.
Human language is abstracted, the same way cries are abstracted. Like, we know Pokemon say their own names, but we hear the in-game cries, and we see how those cries are rendered in text. It takes two brain cells to understand the player is hearing and seeing an abstraction of those spoken words and sounds.
Anonymous
SM also had Anabel literally tell Looker to speak English so she can understand him, but that line was probably different in the Japanese version. But different languages existing in-universe has always been a thing. It's even a plot point in XY's postgame
Anonymous
In Pokémon's timeline, NA was colonised by Kalos. Unovans are baguette eaters
Anonymous
>>58827839 >>58827822 >カロスに留学されていた オーキド博士のお孫さん ボンジュールは使いこなすのにさようならはバイビー!なのよね Professor Orchid's grandson studied abroad in Kalos, he's good at saying "bonjour", but when he says goodbye he uses "bye-bye!" Anonymous
>>58827890 >Like, we know Pokemon say their own names Do they really? I always felt like that was an anime-only thing. When a Pokémon does their cry in the game it's labelled as them going Jigglypuff or whatever because to me that's just how they write Pokémon onomatopoeias
Anonymous
>>58827939 Unless paldeans also speak french and nobody speaks spanish that can't be the case, because unovans speak the same language as paldeans
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827934 >どっ…… どうされたんですか?その 口調……それに なにが あったんです?そんなに あわてられて…… No mentions of different languages here
Anonymous
>>58827957 In Pokémon's timeline Kalos also won the war of Paldean succession
Anonymous
>>58827967 Unlikely given that would mean no region speaks spanish, and spanish is even used in pokemon names both in english and japanese.
Anonymous
>>58827975 Consider this: Pokémon names in Spanish are the same as in English, whereas some other languages like French or German gets their own names. Therefore this obviously means that Spanish is an extinct language in the Pokémon universe. My logic is flawless
Anonymous
>>58827994 That sounds cool but unlikely.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827994 >>58828003 I don't know how often is spanish used in japanese Pokemon games but Juan is literally called Adán in japanese. Not Adam (アダム) the english version, but the spanish Adán (アダン) so clearly there's still spanish there
Anonymous
I wait for the region based on Italy so we learn something about the PokéRoman Empire
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58828052 Can't wait for Falinks regional form with an evo there
Anonymous
>>58827392 >and has the language teacher confirming Unova does speak the same language as Paldea Okay but is that actually confirmed on the Japanese version of the script? For all we know it could just be a localization thing; not to mention, it could also be a slight twist of the original if they did say that, like maybe the way it's expressed in Japanese meant it more like saying that Unova is bilingual
Anonymous
>>58827392 >>58829251 and to elaborate a bit on that, here is a screenshot of what he says in English, the way it's phrased, it could go two ways, either he does mean Unovans either share or are capable of speaking the Paldean language; or, Salvatore was referring to the Blueberry Academy, rather than Unova as a whole, unless it's mentioned more explicitly in Japanese then it's just up to the player's interpretation
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827943 >bye-bye -> smell ya later weird
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827934 >English >When there is no England DEEPEST LORE
Anonymous
>>58828052 >It's symbol is a giant Kilowattrel Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58828052 >>58830336 >regional legion-themed pawniard line Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58829300 >https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AthITekgEzE at 12:41 Also, even the english has him say "Unova Region" right before.
Let it go.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58829251 >>58829300 >言葉は パルデアと 一緒だけど文化は ちょっぴり 違うかも!?セイジの授業 役に立ってる!?(The language is the same as Paldea, but the culture might be a little different!? Are Sage's (Salvatore's) lessons useful?!) Doesn't sound as if paldean is just one of multiple languages unovan speak imo, and certainly it's not talking about just the academy, but Unovan's culture. Same language, different customs
Anonymous
Also, Laventon literally speaks English sometimes in the Japanese version of PLA, which fits with him being implied to be from Galar.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827944 The ways cries are written is typically based on their Japanese names. Jigglypuff says "Pu Pu", Clefairy says "Pi Pi". It's the same discrepancy as anime/Smash/Pokken Charizard saying "Liza" or Onyx says "Iwaa".
They literally say their name in universe. How we hear it or read it is abstracted through multiple layers of localization choices (or lack thereof).
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827571 >in the ideal version of the US everyone speaks spanish, don't go bankrupt for injuries as there's free healthcare, you can traverse everything by foot just fine instead of having everything designed for cars, there's plenty of wild life, green areas and actual housing instead of glorified strip malls, everyone respect each other, more or less attune with the ancient culture that precedes them and potential dictators have to gain motion by appealing to people's sensibility and care for those with less rights What a critique to immigration
Anonymous
Anonymous
I refuse to accept all Pokemon games have the same canon. Each console has its own own canon. I wont change my mind on that.
Anonymous
>>58827392 >britbong Pokemon is forced to have curry for dishes >also forced to have india tongue instead of Unovian speak Lmao
Anonymous
>>58830783 You mean either "universe" or "continuity".
There can't be, by definition, more than one canon.
Anonymous
>>58831197 See
>>58830436 Indians don't have a language in Pokémon, at least so far. Galarians speak english, unovans speak spanish.
Anonymous
>>58831923 Why would a region be based on the USA speak Spanish
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58831984 >why would the USA speak spanish lmao
Also have you ever tried reading a thread before posting? I will summ it for you
>galarians speak english >Looker doesn't know english but can communicate in unova >unovans speak the same language as paldeans Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58827462 Wait so spics have been copying english names for 28 years and are only pretending to have creativity now?
Anonymous
>>58831208 >There can't be, by definition, more than one canon. Anonymous
>>58832584 He's right, retard, you can have multiple continuities, but only one of them is canon.
Anonymous
>>58832601 I'm not talking about continuity Mr. Faggot, there isn't an overlapping canon for the series. The games in the same console share a canon, they don't share a canon cross-console. Now go be a faggot somewhere else, maybe watch some more of those youtube videos where they read bulbapedia articles for you.
Anonymous
Quoted By:
>>58832616 >no no no Emerald and Platinum have completely different continuities-I MEAN CANONS and if you disagree you... um... you... watch dumb videos on youtube yes that's it! Ha! Thanks for letting us know your mother drank through the pregnancy