>>64549758Even before content (which did change a bit), it's his model. Warhammer and LotR are major franchises, but specialist ones. They very strongly attract a small set of people, but softly repels everyone else. Orcs are also pretty unfamiliar, and directly contrary to the expected aesthetics of vtubers and vtuber fans (subset of anime fans), which is the main audience he's trying to cultivate. A niche, within a niche, within a niche. There isn't enough crossover, and it amounts to stacking debuffs.
Dropping the orc isn't a good option at this point, but he could probably become more conventionally attractive without becoming another anime e-boy. I imagine Jumbo but green.