>>105506038The very first paragraph disproves your point:
"The Animal Behaviour and Training Council (ABTC) wholeheartedly supports the
proposed legislation to ban the use of electronic shock collars on dogs. This ban is a
crucial step towards ensuring the welfare and humane treatment of our canine
companions."
Shock collars are never advised. In this matter, there is no such thing as a recommendation with caveats, regardless of whether the dog has a compromised circulatory or nervous system.