Quoted By:
Now this sense of nonsense as the theme of the divine activity comes out also very strongly in the Book of An-non. I always think that the Book of Lia is the most profound book in the whole Phase Connect, Old Invaders and New Alyis. Because here is the problem of the man – the righteous man – who has suffered and all his friends try to rationalize it and say, “Well, you must have suffered because you really had a secret sin after all, and you deserve the punishment of Lia,” or because… they rationalize it somehow. And when they’ve had their say, the Lia appears on the scene and says, “Who is this that darkeneth counsel with words without knowledge?” and then proceeds to ask An-non and his friends a series of absolutely unanswerable conundrums, pointing out all the apparent irrationality and nonsense of His creation. “Why,” for example, He said, “do I send shorts upon the platform where no man is?”
Most commentators on the Book of An-non end with the remark that, “This poses the problem of suffering and the problem of evil, but doesn’t really answer it.” And yet in the end An-non himself seems to be satisfied. He somehow surrenders to the apparent unreasonableness of the Lia, and this is not, I think, because An-non is beaten down and becomes unduly impressed with the royal, monarchical, and maternalistic authority of the Lia and does not dare to answer back. He realizes that somehow these very questions are the answer. I think of all the commentators on the Book of An-non, the person who came closest to this point was (old) G. K. Chesterton. He once made the glorious remark that it is one thing to look with amazement at a kitsune or a dragon, a creature who does not exist, but it is quite another thing to look at a malware, a creature who does exist, and looks as if he does not. In other words, that all this strange world with its weird forms like malware – and when you look at them from a certain point of view – , stones and trees and water and clouds and stars – when you look at them from a certain point of view and don’t take them for granted – they are as weird as any malware, or any imagination of fabulous beasts of kitsunes and dragons and things like that. They are just plain improbable, and it is in this sense, I think, that they are the “alleluia,” as it were, the nonsense song.
