Quoted By:
Can anyone give a sort of critique as to why Joker 2 is bad?
I mean actual film critique, like inconsistencies in the narrative, or characters acting out of character without natural progression, or logical leaps that don't make sense within the movie itself.
Because everyone in this thread keeps spouting "Director hates you! Arthur gets raped! Arthur dies!" but there is no actual analysis of film writing itself, just "I don't like" statements that have nothing to do with people normally judge movies.
Like, why would I care if the director hates me? Death of the author, he doesn't matter, the work does.
Why does tragedy occurring in a movie mean the movie is bad, plenty of movies are tragic where the protagonist loses that we all consider good movies.