>>30238189>animation doesn't bring anything newanimation brings something new by default, it doesnt have to have new events or scenes or dialogue to bring something new.
Good adaptation is good on its own, not requiring any comparison to source material. They are not made with assumption that audience has any experience with the original and reading source is not requirement for a complete and intended experience by the creators.
So its not the opposite of what i said, you are just not understanding the idea. No one makes adaptations specifically for fans of source, with exception of something like dies irae fan funded anime.
>Adaptations can't be judged as stand alone because they don't stand aloneThat makes absolutely no sense , and pretty much no one believes this, you have some bad unpopular take there. Adaptations are all intended by the creators to be stand alone and theyre judged as such by pretty much every at least half-decent critic. People who review Game of Thrones review it as it is, ignoring books. Making comparisons to source is a completely different perspective with different goals.
>Hellsing Ultimate is basically a copy paste of the manga in animeAnd that is what the audience wants and that's what makes it a good adaptation. It doesnt change anything because its not necessary, what it adds is amazing voice acting, soundtrack and animation.
Again, you are doing what the other poster did and place no value at all on all the things manga lacks and anime adds. If you do then it clearly matters very little to you. The kind of person who would watch anime on 2x speed or while playing a video game. You cant appreciate all those aspects unless you give them full attention.
> LN in general is a consequence of your lack of imagination and inability to focus when readingbullshit, this just unjustified elitism. Ive read song of ice and fire, i have plenty of imagination. Imagination isnt comparable substitute to real actors and soundtrack, it cant. It seems more like its your own deficiency in ability to appreciate performances of actors, nuances, expression of animation, the soundtrack. All of which are artistic disciplines which you have little respect for it seems. Clearly not into sakuga either.
>you have to actually read the words, progress in the book, moving the pages.Youre almost acting like absence of something results in something greater, dont be a pseudo intellectual. youre not making sense. And making really dumb emotional appeal.
Its logically fallacious. More effort = better? You also actually have to read or listen the words in anime, you have to pay attention to nuances of voices and process visuals. Yes you also need to make effort watching to not miss anything, and just like you miss things watching, you can miss things reading too. You can re-read pages and you can rewatch scenes if needed.
>nothing about booksassumptions, assumptions, assumptions. Stop jerking yourself off. Your arguments are not very logical and making conjectures not based on facts but your biases. Good example of dunning kruger.
>fit his vision, while adding nothingLmao, new scenes, locations and events and attention to detail original doesnt have. Shouldve paid more attention, and as predicted you have no respect or appreciation of what anime does best and are guided solely by biases.
Try actually reading any HF animation material instead of regurgitating reddit.
