>>72048103>When did the livers started losing subs?>After the black video.Incorrect, actually! If you look at Playboard, you'll see there was a pretty universal drop in subs on the day Selen's termination notice went out, presumably from her hardcore fans dumping the company.
Here's Elira's subcount, for reference. She lost around 9k subs in the week between the termination and the black video (606k > 597k), then lost 31k more in the week after the video (597k > 566k).
The black screen may have caused a much sharper drop in subs (especially for people like Elira who were directly involved in it), but it wasn't the start of the decline.
It's also worth noting that the initial drop had actually levelled out before the black video came out. A couple people were even starting to bounce back; Finana, for example, gained like 2k subs from the new song she dropped on the 10th. If they'd just kept their damn mouths shut, they'd probably have been fine—but no, they just HAD to reopen the wound by taking another swing, and now the bleeding shows no signs of stopping. Great work shooting yourselves in the foot, guys! 