>>106654310content ≠ characterization
You can't cite the sentence where I said that list would be the core reasons they have an audience, because I never said my summary is the reason why they have an audience.
I said it's what you're going to get yourself into if you start watching them.
My point on Alana is the closest to your claim of the core reason why she'd have a audience.
She doesn't sing
she doesn't play games
she doesn't do ASMR
she's not even passable as a political commentator like Rev or Nux.
Her only tangible use is being an anti-woke quirk chungus with an anime fox model for people with reddit/9gag adjacent humour. She's relatively weak in collabs, her unique knowledge of the Russian language is painfully underutilized, and her perception of being "based" is heavily contingent on cussing & farming anti reddit threads because she feels left out whenever there's a new chud list without her on Xitter and/or Bluesky.
That is niche she carved out of those whom watch VTubers.