>>106092600Gameplay, story, and atmosphere/suspense imo
Alien Isolation for example works because you have a lot of counters, but the alien learns to work around so it's a fun game of cat and mouse
This game doesn't work because you're basically just stuck running and hiding from the monster and if he catches you're fucked
Both games basically are "hide and seek with an occasional puzzle" but Alien Iso feels better to play cuz the player is allowed more agency and managing your resources/planning how to juke the alien adds suspense/tension