>>22617263There's a little misunderstanding here. And a big post to come.
First, vtuber idols are pretty different from actual idols and much more lax, your character is the idol. Technically all HoloJP are idols even Botan, and most can't dance, not all can sing.
For Nyaru the dancing part is ??? it has no importance until a 3D model is obtained and even then doesn't track so well that good or bad dancing would be distinguished
The singing yes she's lacking there, it's not a deal breaker however as it's not such a disaster that it couldn't be edited clean for song or cover releases. It's acceptable to be more natural "live" which are more often about fun/energy, and have clean releases.
The point is, she's been hard carrying S-pro, first with Yoro and now with Phoebe for more than a year
Seriously check the rest of the team :
>valentinhttps://twitchtracker.com/cupidvalenyan/streams 10ccv literally stopped streaming a year ago (still listed on their site like the rest)
>kohanahttps://twitchtracker.com/amanokohana/streams basically 15ccv stopped streaming last July, still listed
>lavihttps://twitchtracker.com/lavifarseille/streams ~10ccv stream usually 1 to 2 times a month (wtf is this model quality?)
>tatsuriihttps://twitchtracker.com/tatsurii/streams has been streaming since 2017 regularly, every single day this year (with intent to do the full 365/365), but not much incline so far stayed around 20-25 since January (props for the effort though)
etc.
about half of them gave up basically
What does S-pro even does?
Their only description is
>We support artists, musicians, singers, songwriters, and performers in our neighboring communities. Our goal is to create a space for creators, performers, and people to be comfortable with who they are, and who they want to be.In term of bland platitude saying nothing with many words it's up there, and they have a full staff
https://www.shirayuripro.com/about with producer co-producer, pr director (what even does he do)n 5 support staffs... those people must be paid I assume, with which money? Do they take a share of the vtubers revenue? Then for what in exchange, certainly not an audience, most people don't even know nyaru is in this agence, they brought 0, nyaru paid her own model, does everythging herself, didn't get to release a single song (yoro ended up doing those herself).
Aren't they just a parasite at this point? the 2-3 who lead pay some unknown staff nobody sees the work of?
And at last, the big post earlier did mention Nyaru management capabilities, already in the past she shifted more to a role of managing, counselling, organisation. Of course I don't know what she wants exactly but it's not unthinkable of her to have a role similar to (RIP) Slugma from Tsunderia who manage others while still streaming a bit. But honestly even indie, from the limited info available, seems better than this.
