>>45546831she was unironically the least witty girl in 3rd gen, the quickest to resort to the most tired gags and the most likely to drown when given a chance to speak in group collabs. She had surprisingly bad chemistry with just about every other holo she collabbed with.
3rd gen ends up being better off without her, which is an unfortunate thing to observe but she genuinely didn't do a great job fitting into their dynamic
As a solo streamer though, while I thought she was kinda boring, (her gameplay and commentary wasn't particularly interesting, her zatsus weren't especially engaging, and she essentially never did any interesting kikaku streams), I think that about a lot of the girls, and more importantly she did an okay job providing to a niche who wanted that GFE style parasocial relationship.
It's hard to argue with her numbers for example, her YouTube channel is TO THIS DAY still the most superchatted of all time, even after giving every other YouTube channel on planet Earth more than a year to catch up to her after she got shitcanned.
Her concurrent viewership was also impressive, her 2022 median peak ccv was 17k and her mean was 23k over 21 streams in that month and 11 days. That kind of viewership, even if you assumed literally 0 growth from the time she got fired to now, would be good for 5th best across the WHOLE COMPANY, behind only Marine, Pekora, Miko, and Kanata, based on February 2023 numbers. That's a big deal! The 5th most watched girl in Hololive would be massive, and that was assuming she didn't continue to grow!
Apart from that, her design was fine, and her voice was one of the most pleasing to listen to. You would think more vtubers would have nice voices, but out of holos she was one of the few who you could say genuinely did, definitely on the top tier of voices of the company just by having a cute voice without it obviously being forced or strained, unlike solidly half of the rest of the company who clearly have to struggle to speak the way they do.
Overall I'm personally happy she's gone if only because I thought she brought the average entertainment value down in collabs with other girls, who I think are all better off for not having to share airtime with her. But there's no denying she was a big deal with plenty of fans, the numbers don't lie. And honestly while she seemed like a menhera, conniving mess I didn't dislike her as a person when she wasn't being a boring fuckup in collabs. She was likeable enough.
