>>6293565I don't think Amelia is tone deaf, I think she's just bad. She simply doesn't have a voice for it.
And I think she's self-aware about it, during her last unarchived karaoke she occasionally sung purposefully bad just to have fun and to fuck with her audience.
I'd say Noel is tone deaf on top of not having a voice for it. She could not hit her notes during Connected Fantasia to save her life.