>>78915936What you're seeing is the
> no CGDCT buffeffect.
If she were CGDCT she would be praised to the high heavens, all these minor flaws forgotten.
She's currently being judged objectively as a singer, compared to other artists and found wanting.
Because if she's not a cute girl, she will need to be talented ABOVE AND BEYOND in order to objectively attract people to her singing. Also she was recruited for her singing despite all her debuffs so higher standards are to be expected.
You can see the opposite in the response to Green. She's also mid and 100% less talented than Red in that department, but she will only ever get praise because she doesn't NEED to be some ultra talented singer as long as she's CGDCT and follows the idol road to improvement.