>>93411346Focusing only in the movies, the second one, because the character arc and progression was equally good but the paid off wasn't cut abrupt like in the third one.
Third one would be first place for me because they managed Shadow's parallels to Sonic amazingly well done, but they burned too much screen time in jokes, plus that fight between Gerald and Robotnik could have been an email dear God, also please don't kill the grampa like that, make him die by his own hands and don't make Tails and Knuckles murder accomplices lmao