>>2172029>But isn't that supposed to be how it is?Maybe. To me it looks too abrupt. My problem is that the shape of her eyes doesn't seem to follow a full curve, especially near the bottom, it's hard to explain. The inner color also overlaps the outline at the bottom. It's something that looks off to me but if you prefer it this way, that is fine too, it comes down to preferences.
>What do you mean by pinching the bottom of it?If you have a node at the very bottom of your circle shape, try shortening both the left and right handles. Although, now that I've tried reproducing the eye on the left myself, I didn't really need to do that, by just using the ellipse tool and moving around the nodes and handles I got something that looks satisfactory to me. I'll attach my take on the left eye.