>>2251704>>2251698To be fair, the only unwritten rule of /imt/ for editors is to provide at least one file meeting the requester's exact specifications, or at least as close as possible. That said, this is a pretty simply crop job and all of the options provided are valid interpretations of the request.
Here is my personal favorite of the 6 options provided in 1080x2340. Let's all leave it at that.