I can't really rate objectively, so I'll just share some of my thoughts instead.
>>5681232I find it more pleasing to my eyes than I probably should. Very greatly put together, can't wait for the Firefox CSS.
>>5681542Love the wallpaper.
Otherwise a well made base, nothing special, but nothing messed up.
>>5681573I've really seen too much of Enigma, but the color scheme of the desktop is pretty great.
If you want this to actually look good, try without the icons.
>>5681592One of the best. I - for one - really love how bright it is, and the contrast is just perfect.
>>5681662Love how you made use of the wallpaper.
>>5681684That's about as simple as it gets. Maybe a bit overly so, but can't say it's for the worse.
