I have bad taste and normie taste, but my top five in order from favorite to least favorite are:
>Suzumiya Haruhi No Yuutsu
>Steins;Gate
>Yahari Ore No Seishun
>Madoka Magica
>Spice and Wolf
This is also controversial among anime snobs, but I am a big fan of shows like Love Live! and idolm@ster because of the positivity and cheer they bring after you watch them. I get a warm fuzzy happy feeling, like there's good in the world.
