[4 / 1 / 1]
Quoted By:
You walk into a room with three paintings.
>one of them is a painting in a rectangular frame, in an abstract expressionist style, about the author's sadness
>one of them is a painting in a round frame, in an impressionist style, about a melancholic girl
>one of them is a painting in a rectangular frame, in a photorealistic style, of an elephant
When leaving the exhibition, you can talk to the other visitors about the paintings. Since no one knows the name or author of the works, you communicate using the nicknames “the abstract one,” “the round one,” and “the elephant one.”
But “abstract,” “round,” and “elephant” are not options within the same category. Abstract is the style of the first, round is the shape of the second, and elephant is the subject of the third. Outside the context of the paintings, these three words also never describe the same family of objects.
There’s no gotcha or implication of absurdity here, of course. People are just communicating effectively. But there’s a name for this diversity of *types of qualities* temporarily playing the same role.
>one of them is a painting in a rectangular frame, in an abstract expressionist style, about the author's sadness
>one of them is a painting in a round frame, in an impressionist style, about a melancholic girl
>one of them is a painting in a rectangular frame, in a photorealistic style, of an elephant
When leaving the exhibition, you can talk to the other visitors about the paintings. Since no one knows the name or author of the works, you communicate using the nicknames “the abstract one,” “the round one,” and “the elephant one.”
But “abstract,” “round,” and “elephant” are not options within the same category. Abstract is the style of the first, round is the shape of the second, and elephant is the subject of the third. Outside the context of the paintings, these three words also never describe the same family of objects.
There’s no gotcha or implication of absurdity here, of course. People are just communicating effectively. But there’s a name for this diversity of *types of qualities* temporarily playing the same role.
